With the sole exclusion of Felucca Cache Treasure Maps (the OP mentioned they were in Trammel...), ALL Treasure Maps from Supply up, that is, Supply, Cache, Hord and Trove, are supposed to carry Alacrity scrolls....
Supply chests provide the best return on investment ~ mana orbs, pardons, SOAs, and other specialized items. Cache chests generally have better armor, jewelry and weapons but they rarely have the good stuff anymore. Fel. cache chests usually have several power scrolls. Other area’s cache chests rarely have any scrolls. All chests may contain treasure maps. All chests may have 8 of the now mostly worthless mysterious fragments.
Yeah, i did a bunch of Ranger's Hoard (Trammel) T-Maps, and didn't get a single Discord SoA. Got a few Tracking SoAs from it though. Need a Discord SoA to boost my GGS gains on one of my full Bards.
Cache maps have a chance of containing alacrities. There's no guarantee of them being in there. You're likely just having a bad streak.
I've done at least two hundred Fel Cache maps and not a single alacrity. Lots of power scrolls thou.
Well, as I mentioned in a Post here above, https://www.uoguide.com/Treasure_Map does indicate that Felucca Cache Maps are supposed NOT to spawn Alacrity scrolls....
Trammel Maps, though, "should", at least if we go with what UOGuide indicates....
Tha UOWiki, instead ( @Mariah ? ) , seems to contradict with UOGuide as it indicates at https://uo.com/wiki/ultima-online-wiki/gameplay/treasure-maps/ All packages supply and above, and on all facets as I read it, are supposed to spawn Alacrity scrolls based on package and facet.... which, as I understand, would seem to indicate that "also" Felucca Cache Maps would yield Alacrity scrolls which, instead, the UOGuide indicates not.....
Some Alacrity scrolls, though, seem not to spawn in Treasure chests or, at the very least, they seem to be much harder to spawn as compared to other Alacrity scrolls, (see this Post here https://forum.uo.com/discussion/comment/43431/#Comment_43431 ) ..... a bug, maybe ?
I mean, why would not any and all Alacrity scrolls have the same exact chances to spawn among them, within their pertaining package type ?
For example, "supposedly" Ranger Treasure Maps should spawn a Fishing Alacrity scroll, along with Animal Lore, Animal Taming, Archery, Discordance, Musicianship, Peacemaking, Provocation, Tinkering, Tracking and Veterinary yet, it seems as though while all these other Alacrity scrolls seem to spawn quite frequently, the Fishing ones do not.... and this should not be, to my opinion, each and every one of these Alacrity scrolls should have an equal 1/11 (or about 9%) chance to spawn within any given Ranger Treasure Map....
For example, "supposedly" Ranger Treasure Maps should spawn a Fishing Alacrity scroll, along with Animal Lore, Animal Taming, Archery, Discordance, Musicianship, Peacemaking, Provocation, Tinkering, Tracking and Veterinary yet, it seems as though while all these other Alacrity scrolls seem to spawn quite frequently, the Fishing ones do not.... and this should not be, to my opinion, each and every one of these Alacrity scrolls should have an equal 1/11 (or about 9%) chance to spawn within any given Ranger Treasure Map....
I've equal amounts of all of this alacrity scrolls, so your sample amount is probably to low. After 1000 scrolls you might get close to see if there is any strangness in the distribrution of the scrolls, but my guess is that you might have 20 or so and are upset that you haven't got 2 fishing.
I have 4 fish 3 taming 3 lore 2 vet 3 discordance 2 music 1 peace 4 prov. Didn't check how many tinker or tracking I have but my guess it's between 1-4.
For best chance of alacrity scrolls avoid fel maps, where you are likely to get powerscrolls instead (unless you're digging them in hope of powerscrolls of course, my experience )
I've done at least two hundred Fel Cache maps and not a single alacrity. Lots of power scrolls thou.
You two have pointed out the 'ol "two things can be true at the same time" paradigm.
Cache maps in any Facet other than Felucca have a chance to contain an Alacrity Scroll(s) (no Power or Transcendence). -Correct!
Cache maps in the Facet of Felucca have a chance to contain a Power Scroll(s) (no Alacrity or Transcendence). -Also Correct!
*** @Lord_Viro When you're hunting for scrolls, keep in mind what Mariah said above about facets. Power scrolls only spawn in Felucca. Combine that with how the spawn system works and you can dramatically increase your chances of finding a specific item.
Scrolls are part of a "spawn pool": Alacrity Scrolls Transcendence Scrolls Power Scrolls T-maps for one level higher
Cache maps can only spawn 3 items from the above "pool". Hoard maps can only spawn 4 items from the above "pool". Trove maps can only spawn 5 items from the above "pool".
If you're looking for Alacrity scrolls in particular: avoid Felucca to eliminate Power Scrolls and dig Trove maps, as that both eliminates t-maps for one level higher and yields up to five items per chest.
So, for Trammel Trove, you have a chance to get up to five items from the "spawn pool" and the "spawn pool" is reduced to only 2 items: Alacrity Scrolls Transcendence Scrolls
I do maps on all facets and have had to start my third book for blues my second for ps but my pink book only half full i do use them a lot but feel it's all just the fickle RNG gods..
Acknowledgment and accountability go a long way...
Will check my spreadsheet. SOT stash, SOA supply, cache none, hoard and trove both kinds has been my experience now for a long time. Trammel only. Don’t do that many Fel. chests. Only done a few trove.
Last 57 cache chests i(Trammel and Malas) 14 treasure maps and 22 sets of mysterious fragments. No forged pardons or mana orbs. A few coffin pieces, ancient weapons, and skull weapons. No SOAs, not even one. Before the sets of 8 mysterious fragments started appearing in these chests I regularly got much better loot as far as the special items were concerned. Understand UO may have changed the classification of some items and this may have affected how often certain items appeared in chests.
At the time the sets of fragments started appearing, the same thing happened to the loot in supply chests. However, maybe 6 to 12 months ago the loot in these chests suddenly improved and now I regularly get tasty treats, skeleton keys, mana orbs, forged pardons, SOAs and other special items I would expect from these chests. But, cache chests stayed the same.
Not to send this thread off topic but I just finally did a few Eodon maps yesterday (haven't T-Hunted since before all the new content last year) and when I put them into the Davies locker they say TerMur... is that expected?
I have other TerMur maps in my locker that are actually TerMur so wasn't sure if maybe it was just me.
Not to send this thread off topic but I just finally did a few Eodon maps yesterday (haven't T-Hunted since before all the new content last year) and when I put them into the Davies locker they say TerMur... is that expected?
I have other TerMur maps in my locker that are actually TerMur so wasn't sure if maybe it was just me.
That is a known issue. You can tell which are Eodon from the north/south coordinates in the davies as you can see on these facet maps:
When you're hunting for scrolls, keep in mind what Mariah said above about facets. Power scrolls only spawn in Felucca. Combine that with how the spawn system works and you can dramatically increase your chances of finding a specific item.
Scrolls are part of a "spawn pool": Alacrity Scrolls Transcendence Scrolls Power Scrolls T-maps for one level higher
Cache maps can only spawn 3 items from the above "pool". Hoard maps can only spawn 4 items from the above "pool". Trove maps can only spawn 5 items from the above "pool".
If you're looking for Alacrity scrolls in particular: avoid Felucca to eliminate Power Scrolls and dig Trove maps, as that both eliminates t-maps for one level higher and yields up to five items per chest.
I did a total of 6 Trammel Cache. All chests popped up as either Gold or Silver. in two of those chests I received a T-map from a higher level In the other 4 chests I received neither Alacrity, transcendence, nor T-maps.
I just did another 4 maps. this time in Malas. I received neither Alacrity, transcendence, nor T-Map. Now I can understand having a string of bad luck, but this seems to be an exceptional string if so.
I looked back through my spreadsheet, but since my most recent pass with running maps (rather than just testing them) was focusing on Malas Supply and Felucca Cache, I have no recent records for non-Felucca Cache.
Although, you would think 10 non-Felucca Cache should have yielded at least 1 Alacrity (57 non-Felucca Cache should have yielded quiet a few Alacrity!).
From what you and Arnold are posting, it's sounds like something is off with Non-Felucca Cache maps and Alacrity Scrolls.
Finally got some cache chests. Did 5 Malas chests 3 mage and 2 ranger. Collected 214,663 gold from the chests, sold the jewels to a npc for 60,032, and looted 15,510 from the guardians for a total haul of 290,205 gold. Dug up 2 gold, 2 black, and 1 rusty chest. As far as special items go found 2 sets of the mostly worthless mysterious fragments, one ancient weapon, and one hoard map. Also, found about 8 normal items I might use or sell. Oh, almost forgot, no scrolls of any kind.
Probably started doing cache chests around a year ago. My spreadsheet has the results from 262 chests and to be honest I don’t see that I have ever gotten a scroll from a Trammel cache chest. Maybe, they are supposed to have scrolls but that does not appear to be the case.
Well, at this point in time it might be a system better left alone.
Any "fix" would probably result in Alacrity Scolls being added to all Cache maps (Felucca included), thereby reducing the Power Scroll output of Felucca Cache.
You might be right. Just wish mysterious fragments would mysteriously disappear from chests and be replaced by something useful. No reason now they have to win just about every other chest I dig up regardless of the type.
Now that tabards appear to be a mostly permanent addition, with no need to gather many fragments for a limited time event, reducing mysterious fragments to their original spawn rate and amount seems like a good idea to me!
One fragment every 10 chests or so would make them something to look forward to, and something unique t-hunters could gather to sell to those looking for tabards.
Right now fragments are more like, "OMG more!???....I'm leaving them in the chest."
Yes, that is what bothers me about the frags the most. My vendor depends on these chests and hate thinking that each set of fragments represents items I could have actually sold. Don’t need a set of them in every other chest. Just one once in awhile or a bag full that did not count would be fine with me. I leave them in the chest too.
Comments
With the sole exclusion of Felucca Cache Treasure Maps (the OP mentioned they were in Trammel...), ALL Treasure Maps from Supply up, that is, Supply, Cache, Hord and Trove, are supposed to carry Alacrity scrolls....
The UO Wiki https://uo.com/wiki/ultima-online-wiki/gameplay/treasure-maps/ indicates :
Trammel Maps, though, "should", at least if we go with what UOGuide indicates....
Tha UOWiki, instead ( @Mariah ? ) , seems to contradict with UOGuide as it indicates at https://uo.com/wiki/ultima-online-wiki/gameplay/treasure-maps/ All packages supply and above, and on all facets as I read it, are supposed to spawn Alacrity scrolls based on package and facet.... which, as I understand, would seem to indicate that "also" Felucca Cache Maps would yield Alacrity scrolls which, instead, the UOGuide indicates not.....
Some Alacrity scrolls, though, seem not to spawn in Treasure chests or, at the very least, they seem to be much harder to spawn as compared to other Alacrity scrolls, (see this Post here https://forum.uo.com/discussion/comment/43431/#Comment_43431 ) ..... a bug, maybe ?
I mean, why would not any and all Alacrity scrolls have the same exact chances to spawn among them, within their pertaining package type ?
For example, "supposedly" Ranger Treasure Maps should spawn a Fishing Alacrity scroll, along with Animal Lore, Animal Taming, Archery, Discordance, Musicianship, Peacemaking, Provocation, Tinkering, Tracking and Veterinary yet, it seems as though while all these other Alacrity scrolls seem to spawn quite frequently, the Fishing ones do not.... and this should not be, to my opinion, each and every one of these Alacrity scrolls should have an equal 1/11 (or about 9%) chance to spawn within any given Ranger Treasure Map....
I have 4 fish 3 taming 3 lore 2 vet 3 discordance 2 music 1 peace 4 prov. Didn't check how many tinker or tracking I have but my guess it's between 1-4.
Cache maps in any Facet other than Felucca have a chance to contain an Alacrity Scroll(s) (no Power or Transcendence).
-Correct!
Cache maps in the Facet of Felucca have a chance to contain a Power Scroll(s) (no Alacrity or Transcendence).
-Also Correct!
***
@Lord_Viro
When you're hunting for scrolls, keep in mind what Mariah said above about facets. Power scrolls only spawn in Felucca. Combine that with how the spawn system works and you can dramatically increase your chances of finding a specific item.
Scrolls are part of a "spawn pool":
Alacrity Scrolls
Transcendence Scrolls
Power Scrolls
T-maps for one level higher
Cache maps can only spawn 3 items from the above "pool".
Hoard maps can only spawn 4 items from the above "pool".
Trove maps can only spawn 5 items from the above "pool".
If you're looking for Alacrity scrolls in particular: avoid Felucca to eliminate Power Scrolls and dig Trove maps, as that both eliminates t-maps for one level higher and yields up to five items per chest.
So, for Trammel Trove, you have a chance to get up to five items from the "spawn pool" and the "spawn pool" is reduced to only 2 items:
Alacrity Scrolls
Transcendence Scrolls
Good Luck!
At the time the sets of fragments started appearing, the same thing happened to the loot in supply chests. However, maybe 6 to 12 months ago the loot in these chests suddenly improved and now I regularly get tasty treats, skeleton keys, mana orbs, forged pardons, SOAs and other special items I would expect from these chests. But, cache chests stayed the same.
l
I have other TerMur maps in my locker that are actually TerMur so wasn't sure if maybe it was just me.
In regards to you reply here
When you're hunting for scrolls, keep in mind what Mariah said above about facets. Power scrolls only spawn in Felucca. Combine that with how the spawn system works and you can dramatically increase your chances of finding a specific item.
Scrolls are part of a "spawn pool":
Alacrity Scrolls
Transcendence Scrolls
Power Scrolls
T-maps for one level higher
Cache maps can only spawn 3 items from the above "pool".
Hoard maps can only spawn 4 items from the above "pool".
Trove maps can only spawn 5 items from the above "pool".
If you're looking for Alacrity scrolls in particular: avoid Felucca to eliminate Power Scrolls and dig Trove maps, as that both eliminates t-maps for one level higher and yields up to five items per chest.
I did a total of 6 Trammel Cache. All chests popped up as either Gold or Silver.
in two of those chests I received a T-map from a higher level
In the other 4 chests I received neither Alacrity, transcendence, nor T-maps.
I just did another 4 maps. this time in Malas. I received neither Alacrity, transcendence, nor T-Map.
Now I can understand having a string of bad luck, but this seems to be an exceptional string if so.
I looked back through my spreadsheet, but since my most recent pass with running maps (rather than just testing them) was focusing on Malas Supply and Felucca Cache, I have no recent records for non-Felucca Cache.
Although, you would think 10 non-Felucca Cache should have yielded at least 1 Alacrity (57 non-Felucca Cache should have yielded quiet a few Alacrity!).
From what you and Arnold are posting, it's sounds like something is off with Non-Felucca Cache maps and Alacrity Scrolls.
Probably started doing cache chests around a year ago. My spreadsheet has the results from 262 chests and to be honest I don’t see that I have ever gotten a scroll from a Trammel cache chest. Maybe, they are supposed to have scrolls but that does not appear to be the case.
Any "fix" would probably result in Alacrity Scolls being added to all Cache maps (Felucca included), thereby reducing the Power Scroll output of Felucca Cache.
I'ma say....let's forget this one is happening.
One fragment every 10 chests or so would make them something to look forward to, and something unique t-hunters could gather to sell to those looking for tabards.
Right now fragments are more like, "OMG more!???....I'm leaving them in the chest."